View Comments |
Print This Post
|
The Hispanic market continues to grow strongly, but native-born Hispanic Americans, rather than new immigrants, are the real force behind this expansion.
Samuel Huntington argued in his book Who Are We? that Hispanic immigrants were a threat to the national identity of the U.S. because, unlike other ethnic groups, they were not assimilating into the host nation. The news that Univisión Communications, the Spanish-language media conglomerate, is up for sale is one more indication of how wrong this well-respected gentleman is. Univisión controls more than 80 percent of the Spanish-language market but second generation Hispanics prefer English programming and therefore its long-term prospects for growth are small — unless it too assimilates.
There appears to be no reason why owner Jerrold Perenchio should sell. His conglomerate, which includes T.V., radio and music, is a money-making machine. In 1992, Mr. Perenchio bought Univisión for $500 million; today, the media conglomerate has a market capitalization of $10 billion.
However, the demographics are not working in favor of Univisión. Births are outpacing immigration as the key factor in the growth of the Hispanic population in the U.S.. The Hispanic market continues to grow strongly, but native-born Hispanic Americans, rather than new immigrants, are the real force behind this expansion. And — you guessed it — second generation Hispanics speak English and to an increasing extent prefer to read and watch English-language media.
Anyone who is remotely familiar with the Hispanic market has known this for quite a while. I had first-hand experience myself when I worked for a newspaper chain in Florida some years ago. Studies by organizations such as Pew Research Center, the Urban Institute, and Kaiser Family Foundation indicate that American-born Latinos now represent 60 percent of all Latinos; that the second generation is bilingual, has a higher level of education and earns more money than their immigrant parents; and that the third generation doesn’t even speak Spanish. If anything, the stigma that being an immigrant carries in the U.S. nowadays will push the second generation to emphasize their American condition. And newcomers cannot stop that process. In fact, their children will do the same.
For further evidence that American-born Hispanics are assimilating, just look at the numbers of conversions to Protestantism: one-quarter of all Hispanics declare themselves Protestant (40 percent of those even call themselves “born again”). Of course, this is a dubious measure of change because Catholicism has been the principal Christian denomination in the U.S. since the second half of the 19th century!
Mr. Perenchio may have other reasons to sell (say, retiring to Bora-Bora to chase mosquitoes), but it is obvious that the television network, which mainly caters to first-generation Hispanics with voluptuous soap operas, cannot continue to expand in any major way unless it does something drastic. Introducing bilingual programming, for example, might expand Univision’s audience, but it also runs the risk of alienating its first-generation base. The challenge posed by a second generation that has turned away from the Spanish-language media — and not just competition for new electronic media — may be the reason why the network’s advertising revenue has recently been growing at about one-third the rate of T.V. revenue in general.
Young, English-speaking Hispanics would rather watch reality shows like The Real World and comedies like George Lopez, as a recent story in the New York Times pointed out, or listen to “Hurban” radio, a musical hybrid with which Clear Channel is now experimenting.
Of course, no group assimilates without impacting the host culture. But that has been the history of the United States. Every religious or ethnic group that became part of the U.S. nation enriched it without fundamentally altering the basic ideas that inform its institutions. Yes, Hispanics will influence U.S. culture, but it is also true that the prevailing culture, starting with the language, is influencing them a lot more! Many Hispanics appear to want to see their stories reflected in T.V. programming in English. I would be surprised if English-language T.V. networks did not factor that into their future plans. But those stories will be in English and will show Hispanics in the process of assimilating!
Hispanics are not a threat to the identity of the nation. They are a confirmation that there is no such thing as one “national identity” in the U.S. — i.e. an identity that one group imposes on every other group. There is, rather, a flexible, porous culture that continually adopts new shapes within a basic set of institutions made up of liberal democracy, private enterprise, and the rule of law. Like other immigrant groups before them, Hispanics seem to be adapting to that creed while at the same time adding new layers to the complex prevailing culture.
Only sclerotic cultures are destined to die, Mr. Perenchio’s business notwithstanding.
avllosa@independent.org
Visit their website at: http://independent.org
Responses to "The Revolt of the Second Generation"
Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.



I think this essay couches the illegal immagration of Mexicans and
the threat they impose upon the U.S. their "host" country in a
rhetorical parlay of persuasion mildly slanted. It merely speaks much
to say very little. "You thought breaking the law was a threat, "illegal
immagration"". Breaking the law in this manner was not the threat you
thought it was hence; by factual review of our new insight we state,
forerightly, that it was "much adieu over nothing". Relax, it was not
the violation you all had
imagined.
Isn't this really the classical rhetoric of politicians we have grown so
accustomed to? Think about it . . . . where else, other than
on the floors of congress do you hear a mean feminist
female who is asserting her insight towards problems needing
to be addressed as a "gentle lady". Am I the only one who
notices these things?
Comment by TR Freeman | March 22, 2006
That would be great if it were true. It just isn't. Chula Vista is now 80% Mexican and you are hard pressed to hear English spoken any where at any time. I also understand that there is a town along the border that has changed its official language to Spanish, dropping English altogether. If the official language there is Spanish. Assimilation will not occur. And as the population of illegals grows you will see more and more of it.
Comment by Frank | April 16, 2006
Regarding my last post this is the news on the american sity that made its offical language spanish.
Texas Town Adopts Spanish As Official Language
How many Americans know this or can even believe it?
Oddly Enough Headlines taken from this website:
http://www.englishfirst.org/elcenezo/elcenezoreuters81699.htm
Monday August 16 8:14 AM ET
Texas Town Adopts Spanish As Official Language
EL CENIZO, Texas (Reuters) - The border town of El Cenizo, whose population is heavily Hispanic, has adopted
Spanish as its official language and declared the community a safe haven for illegal immigrants, officials said
Friday.
The ramshackle town of 7,800 people is located just south of Laredo, Texas, across the Rio Grande River from
Mexico.
Mayor Rafael Rodriguez told Reuters that he and most of the town's residents speak only Spanish. Many are first-
generation immigrants, both legal and illegal. Rodriguez himself crossed into the United States illegally from
Mexico but became a U.S. citizen in 1995.
"In past administrations, the meetings were done in English and they did not explain anything," Rodriguez said.
The result, he said, was widespread apathy.
The City Council voted last week to make Spanish, not English, the town's official language. That means that town
business will be conducted in Spanish, which then will be translated into English for official documents to meet
the requirements of Texas law.
Rodriguez says the City Council's intent was not to usurp English or create divisions, but to make local
government more accessible to the town's residents.
"What we are looking for is that the people of the community who attend the meetings and who only speak Spanish
be able to voice their opinions," Rodriguez said.
The "safe haven" ordinance forbids city staff, which consists of one employee and two volunteers, from helping
the U.S. Border Patrol find illegal immigrants or inquiring about any person's immigration status.
The intent was to avoid meddling in peoples' lives, Rodriguez said.
"We are not protecting them and neither are we turning them in," he said.
City Secretary Elsa Degollado estimated that the town's population currently includes 1,000 illegal immigrants.
Rodriguez said he did not expect any reprisals triggered by the new ordinances.
But Linda Evans, a spokeswoman for Texas Gov. George W. Bush, said his office has contacted "relevant state and
federal authorities to ensure that the laws, including illegal immigration laws, are being enforced."
"As a general rule, Governor Bush believes that government business in America should be conducted in English,"
Evans said.
The measure drew a sharp response from English First, a group based in Springfield, Virginia that advocates
making English America's official language.
The group's executive director, Jim Boulet, said El Cenizo may be the first U.S. town to have adopted Spanish as
its official language — a step that policy makers should take as a "warning sign" of things to come.
"Will we call this town 'America's first Quebec?"' asked Boulet, referring to the French-speaking Canadian
province. "Language divisions rather quickly lead to other divisions."
"It proves we really need a national language policy sooner rather than later," he said.
Comment by Frank | April 16, 2006