It Takes a Village (To Write a Book)
View Comments | Print This Post Print This Post |

by Warner Todd Huston | December 17th, 2007

According to Barbara Feinman, it would have been logistically impossible for Hillary Clinton to write her mediocre political tract without assistance.

Venerable book publishers Simon and Schuster have announced that they will be issuing a new edition of Hillary Clinton's starry-eyed 1996 paean to socialist collectivism, It Takes a Village – starring none other than Mz. inevitability herself, Hillary Clinton. I'm sure the rafters will once again tremble with hosannas for Clinton's "hard work" in writing the book and she will again be heralded as a wonderful stylist. All due praise will be lavished upon the former first lady,
current Senator, and unsurprising candidate for the Democrat Party nomination for President of the United States of America.

Actually, I'll have to take that back because Hillary won't be receiving all due praise for her efforts on the book. She will be getting far, far more than she deserves. Why, you might ask? Because she wrote barely a word of the book that bears her name, that's why. And worse, since 1996 Clinton has lied repeatedly in claiming that she wrote it all by herself, refusing to acknowledge that it was ghostwritten by someone else.

Still, the ersatz praise has already started. As seen on Amazon.com's page for the book, Audiofile magazine recently said of the new edition, "For the most part, this is not the former first lady and presidential hopeful we all know. In a softer, almost neighborly voice, Clinton reveals intimate details about her childhood and the childhood of her husband." This is really quite an observant review for the single fact that Clinton's voice is altogether missing from the book. Of course, the reason
for that is that the harsh, shrill voice of the Hillary Clinton "we all know" was nowhere near the typewriter of Barbara Feinman Todd, the woman who really wrote the book.

But, where is the acknowledgment of the real writer of the book Hillary is famous for? Nowhere to be found, making Hillary more correctly infamous for the book instead of praiseworthy. A description of the book prior to the new edition's release, one probably written by the publisher, says, "Written when Hillary Clinton was the First Lady, It Takes a Village acknowledges the many challenges and difficulties of raising children in America and proposes an ideal of broad community responsibility
for the total upbringing of healthy and secure children. Clinton draws on her own experiences as a child, mother, and lawyer, as well as those of concerned parents, teachers, and advocates for children — and she takes the time to listen to the important lessons that children can teach adults as well."

It's interesting that they don't exactly come out and say she wrote the thing, isn't it?

Since the book was first published in 1996, though, Hillary has repeatedly insisted she wrote the book herself. Boasting that she had "written a 320-page book in longhand" and that it took her "six months" to complete, Clinton has steadfastly refused to credit the actual writer, Barbara Feinman Todd. And this refusal to admit that small truth is odd since even the New York Times contradicts her claims. On April 22nd, 1995, as the book was in the planning stages, the Times reported that it was Feinman who was to do the heavy lifting for the project. In their '95 piece the Times stated,

The book will actually be written by Barbara Feinman, a journalism professor at Georgetown University in Washington. Ms. Feinman will conduct a series of interviews with Mrs. Clinton, who will help edit the resulting text.

Since publication, Hillary Clinton has claimed to have written the tome herself; however, the actual writer begs to differ. In a September 2002 piece that appears on the website for The Association of Writers & Writing Programs (AWP), Barbara Feinman Todd told the odd story of Hillary's failure to credit Feinman for her work on It takes a Village. Trying her best to downplay Clinton's behavior, Feinman sorrowfully relates her tale:

So before I would ultimately hang up the sheet for good, my client list would grow to include an African princess, a congresswoman, two senators, a first lady, a Middle East peace negotiator, and an erstwhile presidential candidate. The First Lady, Hillary Clinton, is the one, predictably, people still bring up to this day. The actual writing experience of working on It Takes a Village with Mrs. Clinton was not extraordinary in any respect. Together with our editor, we produced drafts in a
round-robin style. We worked well as a team and things went about as smoothly as can be expected when you're producing a high-profile book in eight months and one of you is married to the leader of the free world.

The problem came when Mrs. Clinton decided, for reasons still a mystery to me, not to acknowledge my help, or that of anyone else by name. Because the White House had issued a press release early on in the process stating that I had been hired to "help prepare the manuscript," when it was finished and there was no mention of me in the acknowledgments, the anti-Clinton forces went to town. The irony was that by not acknowledging me, rather than diminishing my role, she unwittingly elevated me to a sort of literary Joan of Arc with the likes of everyone from Don Imus to Maureen Dowd to Rush Limbaugh weighing in before Thank-YouGate blew over. Pundits had a field day opining how much of the book she had actually written. The truth was much more prosaic: Like any first lady, Mrs. Clinton had an extremely hectic schedule and writing a book without assistance would have been logistically impossible. The book, despite the fact that it was at best a mediocre political tract on the virtues of governmental responsibility in the raising of children through subsidized programs like Head Start, was a bestseller and its audio version won Mrs. Clinton a Grammy.

In her desire to be the queen of all she purloins, Hillary Clinton couldn't even share a modicum of credit with the woman who actually wrote her book.

As to Feinman's point that Hillary was "too busy" to write the book herself, who can doubt that as First Lady the time to write the "mediocre political tract" that carries her name would have been hard to come by. Unfortunately, there is little doubt that she'll still refuse to admit her actual role with the release of this 10th Anniversary edition, either. And it is doubtful that we could ever expect the MSM to call her on it. It may take a village to raise a child, but Hillary is likely still "too busy" to notice as she takes at least one villager's due credit.

Labels: Elections & Political Parties

Warner Todd Huston is a staff writer for the New Media Alliance, Inc.
wthuston@thenma.org
Visit their website at:

Read more articles by Warner Todd Huston on IntellectualConservative.com

 

Responses to "It Takes a Village (To Write a Book)"

  1. I thought Hillary got $8 million for her book. If so, that's pretty good … $8 million for not working.

    Is this a great country, or what?

    Comment by sedonaman | December 18, 2007

  2. The amazing thing is that the truth about Hillary is known, out in the open, and overall few care. The fact that she may become the next president speaks volumes about where this country is going.

    I suspect when Lenin said, "Useful Idiots," he unwittingly was talking about a great number of current day American voters.

    The problem with the U.S. is that once you're on top the only way to go is down.

    Well, you get what you deserve!

    Comment by NHGrouch | December 27, 2007

  3. The ancient Greeks use to say, "Whom the gods would destroy they first build up."

    Comment by sedonaman | December 27, 2007

Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.







Latest Articles

"Islamo-Fascists" and "White Racists"
 by Jack Kerwick
The Republican Rules Of The Road, According To Colin Powell: (Jacking The GOP From Conservatives)
 by John Quayle
Twelve Years of Iranian Lobby
 by Hassan Daioleslam
Non Compos Mentis
 by Lisa Fabrizio
Obama’s Limited Intelligence
 by Aaron Goldstein
Why Panetta?
 by Phillip Ellis Jackson
Is Israeli Policy Crazy?
 by Ivan Eland
Military Keynesianism to the Rescue?
 by Robert Higgs
Conservative Reformation
 by Alan Roebuck



Book Reviews



Features







         Top 25