Payday loans
Cialis

Solving the Iran Problem Could Help Solve the Palestinian Problem, but not Vice Versa

 Hell will freeze over five times before the jihadists change their ways.

U.S. President Barack H. Obama (and his National Security Advisor, General James Jones, as well as his White House Chief of Staff, Rahm Emanuel), the Quartet's Middle-East Emissary and former U.K. Prime Minister Tony Blair, and German Chancellor Angela Merkel have it backwards: attempting to solve the Palestinian statehood question will not solve the Iranian problem; in fact, it will exacerbate it, as it permits the Tehran regime to continue to play the role of spoiler by its supplying of weaponry, training and funding to its rejectionist Arab proxies: Hizballah in Lebanon and Hamas and Islamic Jihad in Gaza. In assuming that these jihadist terrorist groups can be converted to a position that accepts the sovereign Jewish State of Israel (in whatever configuration of borders) they are as likely to achieve success as they would be in a project seeking to raise Satan back into Heaven and the good graces of God. As the popular saying goes, "Hell will freeze over five times" before the jihadists change their ways.

On the other hand, if the Iranian problem is solved — whether through application of the military option (a difficult and costly operation) or through the application of very stringent sanctions and embargoes, particularly of all refined petroleum products, causing the shaky Iranian economy to implode, and thereby forcing the regime to change its ways (highly unlikely) or else face the wrath of the Iranian people which has supported over 5,000 anti-regime demonstrations and acts of protest annually for the past three years, and risk a popular revolution — whatever causes the Iranian government to change  its tune (reform being unlikely and revolution possible if concessions to the mullah regime are ended), the results will mean that the support for the Arab rejection front — especially the jihadists — will disappear. Without Iranian funds and weaponry, Hamas and Hizballah cannot survive as spoilers. And once these jihadist rejectionists are removed from the picture, Palestinian moderates could be capable of finding their voices once again.

Our three savants have suggested that if Israel only makes more concessions to the Palestinians, it will help the moderate Arab regimes unite against Iran and its nuclear program. Plain and simple: they've got it backwards. Maybe it's because Semitic languages like Hebrew and Arabic go from right to left, and European languages go the opposite way, but the three are not reading events correctly. The truth is that because of convergent interests to prevent radical Islamist groups from gaining power, the moderate Arab states such as Egypt, Jordan, and Morocco, which already have peaceful relations with Israel, and Saudi Arabia, which talks to Israel a lot more behind the scenes than most realize, already are aboard the anti-Iran train. So, while Palestinian statehood is an important issue, it is not the magic catalyst needed to cement together an anti-Iran coalition. The Arab "moderates" already are united in opposing Iran and its blatant interference in Arab affairs in Iraq and Lebanon and covert interference elsewhere throughout the Arab world.

Egypt's recent discovery of a Hizballah network on its soil, attempting not only to smuggle weaponry supplied by Iran through Egypt into Gaza to re-supply Hamas, but also to destabilize Egypt through a series of terrorist attacks on Egyptian soil with particular concentration on Sinai resorts where many of the potential victims are likely to be Israelis, served as a wake-up call to the Mubarak government of the danger that this Iranian proxy poses to the land of the Nile. President Mubarak regarded the Hizballah operation as a threat to Egypt's national security and publicly said as much on April 23rd. Egypt's government-controlled press went so far as to accuse the network of conspiring to stage a coup in Egypt. The Lebanese newspaper al-Mustakbal reports that Egypt has identified four of the 49-member terror network as agents of the al-Quds unit of the Iranian Pasdaran (Islamic Revolution Guard Corps). The result of this discovery, made in late 2008, but kept under wraps until about a month ago, has been to cause Egypt to view Iran as its enemy and Israel as an ally in the war against the Islamist jihad emanating from Tehran and the various branches of the Muslim Brotherhood.

If one follows the recommendations of these three naifs, unfortunately we get results where the jihadists regard themselves as having achieved another victory. Every concession or retreat from territories conquered in wars, whether it be from southern Lebanon occupied from 1982 to 2000 in order to prohibit the PLO and other Palestinian radical groups from attacking northern Israel, or the Gaza Strip — occupied from 1967 to 2005 as a result of the 1967 Six-Day War — has resulted in jihadist groups such as Hizballah (in Lebanon) and Hamas (in Gaza) taking over and using the vacated territories as launching pads for attacks on Israel. Rather than decreasing the antagonism of these radical groups to Israel and the West, retreat has caused them to increase their antagonism as they believe that they are drawing closer to the day of their ultimate victory. The recent attack of the Taliban in Pakistan — breaking out of the Swat Valley and marching into neighboring Buner — is the result of concessions made to the Taliban in earlier agreements made by the Pakistani government that attempted to achieve a ceasefire.

What Obama, Blair, and Merkel seem to forget is that Hamas is a first cousin of al-Qaeda, and al-Qaeda is an ally of the Taliban. All three ultimately are the progeny of the Sunni radical fundamentalist (Islamist) Muslim Brotherhood. And although Hizballah, both in Lebanon and Iraq, is a Shiite radical fundamentalist organization that is loyal to the Khomeinist regime of Supreme Leader Ali Khamenei of the Islamic Republic of Iran, the goals vis-à-vis Israel and the West are remarkably similar despite the doctrinal differences between Shia and Sunni. Israeli Foreign Minister Avigdor Lieberman astutely has asked: "How does one negotiate with a party that seeks one's destruction? What is there to negotiate?" The Iranian mullah regime and its proxies Hizballah and Hamas have been quite open about their shared goals: for 30 years we have heard a steady litany of curses, condemnations, and maledictions upon the West in general and the United States and Israel in particular. In that same time period we have seen that the Islamist Iranian regime has taken every possible opportunity to attack America, as well as American and Western interests. Today, and for the last five years, Iraq in large degree has been a proxy war with Iran.  The resurgence of the Taliban in Afghanistan was aided and abetted through material aid given to the Taliban and al-Qaeda by the Tehran mullahs at the agency of Iran's Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps. That Iran and the Taliban often have been enemies in the past should not blind us to the truth and applicability to our situation of the old Middle-Eastern adage: "The enemy of my enemy is my friend." Iran will support the Taliban and al-Qaeda as long as it is useful to do so in its war with the West.

Returning our focus to the Palestine statehood question, it should be stressed that as long as the radical fundamentalists such as Hamas and Islamic Jihad have a strong voice in Palestinian politics — something that will continue as long as Tehran has the ability to fund and supply these radicals — the voice of the moderates, of people like Professor Sari Nussibeh, will be silenced, and fruitful dialogue stymied. If Obama, Blair, and Merkel really want to hear the voice of moderation from the Palestinian side — and it would behoove them to be sure that Arabic statements correspond with English ones — they will need to take adequate steps to silence the cacophony that issues from the kakistocracy of Tehran.

One of the quickest ways to alert the Tehran regime that we are no longer taken in by its ruses and subterfuges, and that we indeed mean business, is to undo the ridiculous 1997 political error of placing the principal Iranian opposition movement, the People's Mojahedin Organization of Iran (PMOI), aka Mojahedin-e Khalq (MEK), on the U.S. Department of State's Foreign Terrorist Organization list (FTO). Done as a political gift to the Khatami regime, it was a travesty of justice as well as a political blunder, and should be reversed just as similar proscriptions were removed in the U.K and the E.U. at the order of the respective high courts of each as they reviewed the case earlier this year. Leveling the playing field between the Iranian opposition and the Tehran regime costs us nothing; it just might allow the Iranian people to save everyone else a lot of grief as they rescue their democratic revolution from the hands of the mullahs who hijacked and destroyed it 30 years ago.

The Obama administration has made it a hallmark of its policy to oppose any and all abuse of human rights, especially of minorities and women. If this noble policy is to have validity, it must be applied equally throughout the world. The Obama government cannot close its eyes to Iran's 30-year abysmal record on human rights and continue to protect the mullah regime from its democratic opposition, the PMOI/MEK. Now is the time to take the PMOI off of the FTO, an action requested of President Obama by 503 European parliamentarians just this past week. If this is done, the mullahs will finally begin to take us seriously and realize that we mean what we say. But, as long as the PMOI remains on the FTO, Tehran knows that we are bluffing, and that we're doing a lousy job of it.

Share

1 comment to Solving the Iran Problem Could Help Solve the Palestinian Problem, but not Vice Versa

  • Majid Saatchi

    Thank you Dear Zucker for your great artical .

    Iran, Syria back Palestinian militancy
    Tuesday, 05 May 2009
    AP: The leaders of Iran and Syria reaffirmed their support for “Palestinian resistance” on Tuesday, a defiant message to the U.S. and its Mideast allies who are uneasy over Washington’s efforts to forge closer ties with the hard-line government in Tehran.

    Iran remains most active state sponsor of terrorism: US
    Thursday, 30 April 2009
    AFP: Iran, which continues to plan and finance terrorist attacks in the Middle East and beyond, remains the “most active state sponsor of terrorism” in the world, the US government charged Thursday.

    Euro-MP conspiring with Iranian intelligence?
    Thursday, 30 April 2009
    Iran Focus: London, Apr. 30 – A member of the European Parliament from Portugal has been in direct contact with the Iranian regime’s officials and agents, Iran Focus has learnt.

    Egypt summons Iran envoy over Hezbollah spat
    Tuesday, 21 April 2009
    AFP: The foreign ministry summoned an Iranian official on Tuesday after Iran criticised Egypt’s claim that it had arrested members of Lebanon’s Hezbollah for allegedly planning attacks in the country.

    Gates cool to Iran proposal to train Afghan police
    Friday, 17 April 2009
    AFP: US Secretary of Defense Robert Gates on Thursday was cool to an Iranian proposal to train Afghan police, suggesting that Tehran should first stop arming the Taliban.

    U.S. pushes for U.N. censure of Iran, Syria on arms
    Friday, 17 April 2009
    Wall Street Journal: The Obama administration is pushing for a formal censure of Iran and Syria at the United Nations over an arms-smuggling case that U.S. officials see as highlighting the risks that Iranian weapons shipments pose to regional stability.

    Iran enters Egypt-Hezbollah row
    Wednesday, 15 April 2009
    UPI: Egyptian security officials say they have vital information confirming suspicions that Hezbollah was plotting attacks on their country as Iran enters the fray.

    Egypt accuses Iran as police hunt ‘Hezbollah cell’
    Tuesday, 14 April 2009
    AFP: Egyptian Foreign Minister Ahmed Abul Gheit accused Iran of using the Lebanese Shiite militant group Hezbollah to gain a foothold in Egypt, in a newspaper interview published on Tuesday.

    NYPD sees threat in Israel-Iran tensions
    Saturday, 04 April 2009
    AP: The New York Police Department has prepared plans to beef up security at the city’s synagogues and other Jewish sites amid escalating tensions between Israel and Iran, officials confirmed Friday.

    Alleged Israeli attack draws attention to Sudan’s ties to Iran
    Wednesday, 01 April 2009
    VOA News: Reports that Israel may have carried out an air attack on an Iranian weapons convoy in the Sudanese desert 2.5 months ago have drawn attention to an alleged Iranian arms smuggling network in Africa.

    Israeli drones destroy rocket-smuggling convoys in Sudan
    Sunday, 29 March 2009
    Sunday Times: Israel used unmanned drones to attack secret Iranian convoys in Sudan that were trying to smuggle rockets into Gaza. The missiles have the range to strike Tel Aviv and Israel’s nuclear reactor at Dimona, defence sources said.

    US judge orders Iran to pay $25M for Hamas killing
    Friday, 27 March 2009
    AP: A federal judge on Friday ordered Iran to pay $25 million plus interest to the family of Israeli soldier Nachshon Wachsman, who was kidnapped and executed by Hamas in 1994.

    US says Iran increasing activity in Latin America
    Tuesday, 17 March 2009
    Reuters: Iran is increasing its activity in Latin America and the Caribbean, including actions aimed at supporting the Lebanese militant group Hezbollah, a top U.S. military commander said on Tuesday.

    Iran, Hamas defend wanted Sudanese president
    Friday, 06 March 2009
    AP: Iran and the Palestinian militant group Hamas showed their support for Sudan’s president Friday, sending top officials to the Sudanese capital and denouncing the international warrant for his arrest on charges of war crimes in Darfur.

    INTERVIEW-U.S. urges Iran to help not hinder Afghan peace
    Friday, 06 March 2009
    Reuters: The U.S. commander of international forces in Afghanistan accused Iran of supporting the Taliban insurgency and urged Tehran to join international efforts to bring peace to its eastern neighbour.

    Iran looms over Clinton’s Mideast trip
    Thursday, 05 March 2009
    New York Times: Iran is not on Hillary Rodham Clinton’s itinerary in her first swing through the Middle East and Europe as secretary of state. But it is clearly, and constantly, on her mind.

    Abbas warns Iran not to interfere
    Thursday, 05 March 2009
    Washington Times: Palestinian Authority President Mahmoud Abbas told Iran’s supreme leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei on Wednesday to keep out of Palestinian politics after the ayatollah called for armed “resistance” against Israel.

    US accuses Iran’s Khamenei of ‘interference’
    Thursday, 05 March 2009
    AFP: US Secretary of State Hillary Clinton accused Iran’s supreme leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei Wednesday of interference by urging Muslims to join the Palestinian “resistance” against Israel.

    Clinton accuses Iran of seeking to intimidate
    Thursday, 05 March 2009
    AP: U.S. Secretary of State Hillary Rodham Clinton swiped hard at Iran on Wednesday, accusing its hardline leaders of fomenting divisions in the Arab world, promoting terrorism, posing threats to Israel and Europe, and seeking to “intimidate as far as they think their voice can reach.”

    Abbas urges Iran to stop ‘interfering’
    Wednesday, 04 March 2009
    AFP: Iran must stop interfering in Palestinian affairs, president Mahmud Abbas said on Wednesday after talks with US Secretary of State Hillary Clinton.

    Commander says Iran missiles can reach Israel atom sites
    Wednesday, 04 March 2009
    Reuters: Iranian missiles can now reach Israeli nuclear sites, a top Iranian military commander said on Wednesday, but another official held out the prospect of progress in talks on Iran’s disputed nuclear programme.

    Iran’s Khamenei says only ‘resistance’ can save Palestine
    Wednesday, 04 March 2009
    AFP: Iran’s supreme leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei on Wednesday said “resistance” was the only way to save Palestine, as he kicked off a two-day summit organised by Tehran in aid of Gaza and Palestinians.

    Argentine courts seize Iran diplomat’s property
    Tuesday, 03 March 2009
    AP: An Argentine court has ordered a second seizure of property owned by a former cultural attache at Iran’s embassy in Buenos Aires who is sought for his alleged role in a 1994 terrorist attack.

    Afghan officials say seized weapons made in Iran
    Monday, 02 March 2009
    RFE/RL: Afghan officials say weapons seized in a depot in western Afghanistan today were manufactured in Iran.

    Iran gives Taliban helicopter missile
    Sunday, 01 March 2009
    Sunday Times: Iran is supplying the Taliban in Afghanistan with surface-to-air missiles capable of destroying a helicopter, according to American intelligence sources.

    Iran is helping Taliban in Afghanistan, Petraeus says
    Sunday, 15 February 2009
    Bloomberg: Iran is helping Taliban insurgents in Afghanistan, said General David Petraeus, who is in charge of U.S. forces in the Central Asian nation and Iraq.

    Israeli rivals share tough line on Hamas and Iran
    Wednesday, 11 February 2009
    AP: Israel’s new coalition government — whether led by hard-line Benjamin Netanyahu or his moderate rival Tzipi Livni — is likely to take a tough line on two burning issues: Hamas and Iran.

    Hamas chief urges Iran students to help liberate Jerusalem
    Monday, 02 February 2009
    AFP: Hamas political supremo Khaled Meshaal on Monday urged Iranian students to join the Palestinian Islamist movement in helping to liberate Jerusalem so they can “pray together” in the holy city.

    Iran tells Hamas: Be ready for fresh Israeli attacks
    Sunday, 01 February 2009
    Reuters: Iran’s Supreme Leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei told the Palestinian group Hamas to be prepared for possible fresh Israeli attacks on the Gaza Strip, the semi-official Fars news agency reported on Sunday.

    Hamas head in Tehran to meet Iranian leaders
    Sunday, 01 February 2009
    Reuters: A high-level delegation from Hamas arrived in Tehran early on Sunday as part of a regional push to reinforce support for the Palestinian group after the Israeli invasion of Gaza, a Hamas official said.

Leave a Reply

Articles Archived by Topic