is Not Vietnam
08 April 2004
is essential to understand that the Vietnam War was a very different war,
fought for very different reasons, in a very different era of American history.
I can remember being
in Washington, DC to protest the Vietnam War. By then the US was well on
its way to chalking up over 58,000 combat deaths. I think Nixon was in office
by then. Lyndon Baines Johnson had literally lied America into a vastly expanded
war although we wouldn’t learn about that until the famed Pentagon Papers
were revealed by Daniel Elsberg, an analyst who, during the Nixon administration,
concluded that Americans had a right to know how badly things were going.
For those too young to know about Vietnam, other than we lost, the US had
already been in a long Cold War with the Soviet Union since the end of World
War II and there was a theory that, if Vietnam fell to Communist control,
a whole string of other nations would as well. It was called “The Domino
Theory.” Divided between North and South, the Communists in the North wanted
to unite the nation. In the 1950s, the US had fought in Korea when the same
scenario unfolded. The stalemate of that war continues today. Under Kennedy,
“military advisors” had been sent after the French, Vietnam’s former colonial
power, pulled out. Under LBJ it escalated into a full-blown US conflict.
It took several years, but after seeing the carnage on their television news
every night, most Americans began to think it was the wrong war fought in
the wrong place. It would be the first war America lost and, as it wound
down, nobody cared much. We just wanted to get out and bring our military
home. Ironically, the lessons of that war would be applied by one of its
participants, Colin Powell, who, when he became chairman of the Joint Chiefs
of Staff, applied what was be known as the Powell Doctrine. No future war
would be fought with anything less than overwhelming force. It was the principle
applied in the Gulf War and again in Iraqi Freedom to astonishing success.
Powell would tell you, along with the other Neocons surrounding Bush43, that
they emerged from the Vietnam War determined to rebuild America’s military
into the most powerful the world would ever see. Defeat leaves a bad taste
in your mouth. It would take until Ronald Reagan to make that goal come true.
Reagan would leave Bush41 a military second to none. Modern warfare, a totally
integrated fighting machine, began in the Gulf War and it restored national
In the years that preceded the Gulf War, however, the US looked like a paper
tiger. That impression didn’t happen overnight. The Islamic Jihad had its
first victory in 1979, seizing control of Iran along with our diplomats.
The mullahs made Jimmy Carter look so lame, Reagan was elected. But Reagan,
too, was tested in 1986 when more than 280 US Marines were killed by a suicide
bomber in Beirut. He pulled our troops out. Later, though, he would bomb
Libya. Its dictator, Muamar Quadaffi, after last year’s Iraq invasion, decided
it was time to give up his arsenal and end his flirtation with Islamic illusions
Something strange happened in American politics. Having elected conservatives
like Reagan and Bush41, Americans voted for a Vietnam War draft-dodger who
made little effort to hide his contempt for the military. The voters would
change control of Congress, giving it to conservative Republicans, and then
wait out a long, embarrassing, but failed process of impeachment. In the
meantime, Bill Clinton would dither and dither when it came to using the
military power at his disposal. He would fail to capture Osama bin Laden
even when the Sudanese offered his head on a plate. Somalia would become
a military mess.
Our enemies would take notice. In 1993, the first bombing of the World Trade
Center took place. Under Clinton, it was treated, in the words of Sen. John
Kerry, as “a law enforcement” problem. By 9-11-2001, it would become the
cause for war. It is a war unlike Vietnam. It is unlike Afghanistan and Iraq.
It is a war that has long since enveloped the whole world. It is a war being
fought in Spain, Saudi Arabia, Turkey, Bali, Kenya, Morocco, the Russian
Republic. It is an “asymmetric” war fought against a fanatical vanguard of
Muslims determined to impose Islam worldwide.
As the election campaign heats up, it is essential to understand that the
Vietnam War was a very different war, fought for very different reasons,
in a very different era of American history.
The notion that it is now being called up as an example of the supposed courage
of Sen. John Kerry or a reason why the war in Iraq was a mistake could not
be more wrong. Sen. Kerry spent about four months total in Vietnam. By contrast,
Secretary of State Colin Powell served two terms of service there, experiencing
plenty of combat before beginning his rise through the ranks. Sen. Kerry
came home and denounced the war, called his fellow soldiers and sailors rapists
and killers. He would become a politician.
It is no accident Bush43 chose a certifiable hero and veteran of the Vietnam
War as his Secretary of State. It is no accident that the Democrats have
done everything in their power to portray Bush43 as being “a deserter” whose
military service was suspect. Bush43 wanted Powell to represent the nation’s
determination to meet and defeat the new enemy of freedom. Sen. Kerry, if
elected, would find as quick an exit from combat as possible.
The Vietnam War presented the US with a choice and some historians suggest
that President Kennedy would likely have withdrawn our small military presence
there. His assassination ended that possibility. The Iraq War was not one
of choice, though its opponents present it as one. Having driven the Taliban
out of Afghanistan after 9-11, regime change in Iraq was absolutely necessary
if the United States was to continue the transformation of the entire Middle
East from being a constant threat to Western civilization. The Middle East,
if this policy is continued, will be composed of modern nation states. The
despots will have been driven from power. That will be our real security!
Waiting to be attacked again is not an option, not a choice. That is why
Bush43 moved swiftly against Afghanistan, created the Department of Homeland
Security, and asked Congress to pass the Patriot Act. The horror of 9-11
sucked a trillion dollars out of our economy and its effect is only now being
overcome. The US economy cannot suffer another 9-11 without putting the basis
of our power at tremendous risk. The war to liberate Iraq is just a down
payment on a more secure future.
Alan Caruba is the author of Warning Signs, published by Merril Press. His weekly commentaries are posted on the Internet site of The National Anxiety Center.
Email Alan Caruba
this Article to a Friend